Page 1
Page 2
Page 3
Page 4
Page 5
Page 6
Page 7
Page 8
Page 9
Page 10
Page 11
Page 12
Page 13
Page 14
Page 15
Page 16
Page 17
Page 18
Page 19
Page 20
17WaiversContinuedfromPage12takenafteraRule11hearingandgenerallyresultsinaknowingandvoluntarypleathatissupportedbyanadequatefactualbasis.InUnitedStatesv.Mitchell24thedefendantspleaagreementex-presslywaivedtheprotectionsofRule410intheeventhewaslaterabletowithdrawhisguiltyplea.Thedefendantsucceededinwithdrawinghisguiltypleaandproceededtotrial.Attrialstate-mentsfromthepleaagreementandpleacolloquywereusedextensivelyinthegovernmentscase-in-chiefandthedefendantwasconvicted.Onap-pealtheTenthCircuitfocusedonwhetherthegovernmentcouldusesuchevidenceinitscase-in-chiefandconcludeditcould.ThecourtreasonedthattheMezzanatoCourtspecificallyfoundRule410protectionscanbewaivedandtherewasnoevidencethatthesuspectdefendantswaiverwasnotknowingandvoluntary.Butguiltypleasinvolvethewaiverofamyriadofrightsincludingamongotherstherighttopleadnotguiltytheprivilegeagainstself-incriminationandtherighttoconfrontaccusers.Thefactthatarightcanbewaivedisnottheissue.Whenapleaiswithdrawnallofthesevalidlywaivedrightsarerestoredandthedefendanthastherighttoajurytrialarightthatwaswaivedtocrossexaminewitnessesarightthatwaswaivedandtherighttorequirethegovernmenttoproveitscasebeyondareasonabledoubtanotherrightthatwaswaived.PresumablythewaiverofRule410sprotectionsisnotrestoredbecauseitsprotectionswerespecificallywaivedinadvanceasalloftheaforementionedrightswerealsowaived.Andthewaiverthatpermitsadmissionofthewithdrawnpleasfactualbasischeapensthegrantoftherighttotrialbecausethegovernmentcanusethesup-posedlywithdrawnadmissionstoproveitscase.AstheKerchevelCourtstatedTheeffectofthecourtsorderpermittingthewithdrawalwastoad-judgethatthepleaofguiltybeheldfornaught.Itssubsequentuseasevidenceagainstpetitionerwasindirectconflictwiththatdetermination.26SummaryMezzanatowasclearthattheprotectionsofRules410and11fcanbewaived.ThismakessenseintheCooperationContextbecausethegovern-mentisusingasuspectdefendantsownwordsagainsthimorher.ButfederalappellatecourtshavebeentooquicktoextendthosewaiverstotheUnconsummated-PleaandWithdrawn-PleaContexts.TheUnconsummated-PleaContextinvolvesadocumentdraftedbyafederalprosecutoruponwhichadefendantissupposedtobethoroughlyexaminedinopencourtbyafederaljudgeinaRule11hearingbeforeitcanbereliedupon.WithoutaRule11hearingadmissionsinapleaagreementareinsufficientlyreliabletobetrusted.TheWithdrawn-PleaContextinvolvesadefend-antwhohasbeenre-giventherighttoatrial.Butthatrightislimitedorevennullifiedbyadmittingthewithdrawnpleaagreement.Suchwaiversshouldnotbeadmissibleagainstdefendants--astheFederalRulesdraftersintended.ForthesereasonsRule410and11fwaivershavenoplaceincriminalpleaagreements.______________________________________1KennethM.MillerisaPartnerwithBienertMillerKatzmanPLC.TheviewsexpressedherearetheauthorsandnotthoseofBienertMillerKatzmanitsclientsortheFBAOC.2274U.S.220223-241927.3Standonv.Whitley994F.2d141714229thCir.1993.4SeeFed.R.Evid.410b.5SeeFed.R.Crim.P.11f.6513U.S.1961995.7Id.at197.TwodissentingjusticesagreedwiththeNinthCircuitthatweareboundtorespecttheintentthattheAd-visoryCommitteesNotestothecongressionallyenactedRulesreveal.Id.at213SouterJ.dissenting.Becauseofthegovernmentsvastlygreaterbargainingpowerinthepleanegotiationsthemajorityruling...willrendertheRuleslargelydeadletters....Id.at211SouterJ.dissenting.8UnitedStatesv.Mezzanato998F.2d145214559thCir.1993.9Id.at1454.10Id.at1455.11Id.at1456.12Id.at1454-55.EndnotescontinuedonPage18